Polish Farm Labour Force from the Perspective of Agricultural Worker Cooperatives
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.53098/wir032017/04Keywords:
agricultural production cooperatives, farming entities, employment, profitabilityAbstract
The paper focuses on comparisons of the size of the labour force between cooperatives and other legal forms of enterprises in agricultural area. Precisely, the purpose of the paper is to analyse differences between cooperatives and other enterprises in the agricultural sector in the context of employment. An empirical analysis is done on the example of Polish agricultural production cooperatives (APC) and other farming entities. The paper brings answers to the following research questions: Do the agricultural cooperatives provide more employment than other farming entities? What was the level of employment in agricultural cooperatives and other farming entities and what will it be? How does the level of employment influence the profitability of agricultural cooperatives and other farming entities?The conclusions are made on the basis of an analysis of the “List of the 300 best agricultural enterprises” prepared by the Institute of Agricultural and Food Economics – the National Research Institute in Poland. The analysis includes the following types of agricultural enterprises: agricultural production cooperatives, government-owned companies, individual farms, private companies and other farming entities. The time range of this research covers the years 2009–2015. The comparisons are made using analysis of variance, extrapolation method and correlation analysis.The main finding is that there are no clear and significant differences between agricultural production cooperatives and other farming entities in terms of the level of employment, its impact on the overall profitability and partially on increase thereof. However, some of the entities are able to create a lot of jobs. Moreover, they can increase the return on sales by increasing the level of employment and maintain the existing jobs even in the time of a crisis.References
Alves G., Burdin G., Dean A. (2016). Workplace democracy and job flows. Journal of Comparative Economics, 44, 258–268.
Babalola Y.A., Tiamiyu R., (2013). Cooperatives Enterprises: A panacea to job creation and economic empowerment. Information and Knowledge Management, 3 (5), 61.
Belloc F. (2017). What deters labour-owned firm creation? Evidence from Italian manufacturing sectors. Journal of Comparative Economics, 45, 139–153.
Ben-Ner A. (1984). On the stability of the cooperative form of organization. Journal of Comparative Economics, 8, 247–260.
Ben-Ner A., Montias J.M., Neuberger E. (1993). Basic issues in organizations: A comparative perspective. Journal of Comparative Economics, 17 (2), 207–242.
Ben-Ner A., Ren T., Flint D. (2011). A sectoral comparison of wage levels and wage inequality in human services industries. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 40, 608–633.
Berman K., Berman M. (1989). An empirical test of the theory of the labour-managed firm. Journal of Comparative Economics, 13, 281–300.
Bijman J., Cechin A., Omta O., Pascucci S. (2013). Decomposing the member relationship in agricultural cooperatives: Implications for commitment. Agribusiness, 29 (1), 39-61.
Bonin J. (1981). The theory of the labour-managed firm from the membership’s perspective with implications for marshallian industry supply. Journal of Comparative Economics, 5, 337–351.
Bowles S., Gintis H. (1996). The distribution of wealth and the viability of the democratic firm. In: P. Ugo, R. Robert (eds). Democracy and Efficiency in the Economic Enterprise (pp. 64–81). New York: Routledge.
Bretos I., Marcuello C. (2017). Revisiting globalization challenges and opportunities in the development of cooperatives. Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, 88 (1), 47–73.
Brewer A., Browning M. (1982). On the employment decision of a labour managed firm. Economica, 49, 141–146.
Brodziński M. (2014). Oblicza polskiej spółdzielczości wiejskiej. Geneza – rozwój – przyszłość. Warszawa: FREL.
Bumbescu S.S. (2015). Performance analysis in agriculture using Du Pont model. Sibiu Alma Mater University Journals, Series A. Economic Sciences, 8 (2), 41–47.
Burdin G. (2014). Are worker-managed firms more likely to fail than conventional enterprises? Evidence from Uruguay. ILR Review, 67 (1), 202–238.
Burdin G., Dean A. (2009). New evidence on wages and employment in worker cooperatives compared with capitalist firms. Journal of Comparative Economics, 37, 517–533.
Burdin G., Dean A. (2012). Revisiting the objectives of worker-managed firms: An empirical assessment. Economic Systems, 36, 160–167.
Chloupková J. (2002). European Cooperative Movement – Background and common denominators. Unit of Economic Working Papers, Copenhagen, Denmark: The Royal Veterinary and Agricultural University, 11.
Conover N., Molina F., Morris K. (1993). Creating Jobs Through Cooperative Development. Davis, California: National Economic Development & Law Center.
Craig B., Pencavel J. (1992). The behavior of workers cooperatives: The plywood companies of the Pacific Northwest. American Economic Review, 82 (5), 1083–1105.
Domar E.D. (1966). The Soviet collective farm as a producer co-operative. American Economic Review, 56, 734–757.
Dow G.K. (1986). Control rights, competitive markets, and the labour management debate. Journal of Comparative Economics, 10, 48–61.
Dow G.K. (1996). Replicating Walrasian equilibria using markets for membership in labour-managed firms. Economic Design, 2, 147–162.
Dow G.K. (2003). Governing the Firm: Workers’ Control in Theory and Practice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Dzun W. (2009). Spółdzielnie produkcji rolnej w procesie przemian systemowych. Zagadnienia Ekonomiki Rolnej, 4, 74–87.
Estrin S. (1982). Long-run responses under self-management. Journal of Comparative Economics, 6, 363–378.
Feng L., Hendrikse G. (2011). Chain interdependencies, measurement problems and efficient governance structure: Cooperatives versus publicly listed firms. European Review of Agricultural Economics, 39 (2), 241–255.
Fisher M.L., Krishnan J., Netessine S. (2006). Retail Store Execution: An Empirical Study. Working papers. https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/0bb1/b85a38d93f69a9d9ccbd2df1e-6ab42bbc979.pdf [accessed: 11.12.2017].
Hendrikse G., Liang Q. (2013). Cooperative CEO identity and efficient governance: Member or outside CEO? Agribusiness, 29 (1), 23–38.
Holtmann A., Idson T. (1993). Wage determination of registered nurses in proprietary and nonprofit nursing homes. Journal of Human Resources, 28, 55–79.
IAFE (2009–2015). List of the 300 best agricultural enterprises. http://www.ierigz.waw.pl/prace-badawcze/ranking-300 [accessed: 11.12.2017].
ILO (2013). Global Employment Trends for Youth 2013 – A generation at risk. Geneva: ILO.
ILO (2014a). Global Employment Trends 2014. Geneva: ILO.
ILO (2014b). World of Work: Migrant Workers Are Not a Commodity. ILO Magazine: Special issue. Geneva: ILO.
Kahana N., Nitzan S. (1989). More on alternative objectives of labour-managed firms. Journal of Comparative Economics, 13, 527–538.
Lampel J., Bhalla A., Jha, P. (2010). Model Growth: Do Employee-owned Businesses Deliver Sustainable Performance? Cass Business School/Employee Ownership Association/John Lewis Partnership. http://www.saxbam.com/_ClientFiles/uploads/Model_Growth___ Do_employee_owned_businesses_deliver_sustainable_growth.pdf [accessed: 14.08.2015].
Mago S., Mazise A., Hofisi C. (2013). Employment generation by co-operatives: Myth or reality? Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences, 4 (3), 761.
Machek O. (2014). The relationship between financial performance and total factor productivity: Evidence from the Czech agricultural sector. International Journal of Social Sciences And Humanity Studies, 6 (2), 57–67.
Martínez-Victoria M.C., Arcas-Lario N., Maté-Sánchez-Val M.L. (2015). Comparison of the Financial Behaviour of Agri-Food Cooperatives with Non-Cooperatives from a Static and Dynamic Perspective: an Empirical Application to Spanish Companies. Cartagena: Comunicaciones Presentadas – Actas del XVIII Congreso AECA, 6.
Matyja M. (2015). Additional education and professional development in Polish agricultural cooperatives. China-USA Business Review, 14 (8), 399–404.
Matrix Evidence (2010). The Employee Ownership Effect: A Review of the Evidence. John Lewis Partnership/Employee Ownership Association/Circle. https://www.employeeownership.co.uk/publications/the-employee-ownership-effect-a-review-of-the-evidence/ [accessed: 14.08.2015].
Miyazaki H. (1984). On success and dissolution of the labour-managed firm in the capitalist economy. Journal of Political Economy, 92, 909–931.
Moene, K.O. (1989). Strong unions or worker control? In: J. Elster, K.O. Moene (eds.), Altenatives to Capitalism (pp. 83–98). New York: Cambridge University Press.
Münkner H.-H. (1995). Chances of Co-operatives in The Future. Marburg: University of Marburg/Lahn.
Münkner H.-H. (2012). Co-operation as a remedy in times of crisis. Agricultural co-operatives in the World. Their roles for rural development and poverty reduction. Marburg Studies on Cooperation and Cooperatives, 58, 21–23.
NCC (2013). Data of National Council of Cooperatives on Agricultural Production Cooperatives. http://www.krs.org.pl/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=30&Itemid=286 [accessed: 11.12.2017].
Nilsson J. (1998). The emergence of new organizational models for agricultural cooperatives. Swedish Journal of Agricultural Sciences, 28, 39–47.
Nilsson J., Svendsen G.L.H., Svendsen G.T. (2012). Are large and complex agricultural cooperatives losing their social capital? Agribusiness, 28 (2), 187–204.
Nuttall G. (2012). Sharing Success: The Nuttall Review of Employee Ownership. https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/31706/12-933-sharing-success-nuttall-review-employee-ownership.pdf [accessed: 14.08.2015].
Pencavel J., Pistaferri L., Schivardi F. (2006). Wages, employment, and capital in capitalist and worker-owned firms. Industrial and Labour Relations Review, 60 (1), 23–44.
Perotin V. (2014). Worker cooperatives: Good, sustainable jobs in the community. Journal of Entrepreneurial and Organizational Diversity, 2 (2), 34–47.
Polat H. (2014). Cooperative response to unemployment in rural and urban Turkey. In: Cooperatives’ Power of Innovation. Texts selected from the international call for papers, International Summit of Cooperatives, Quebeck. https://www.sommetinter.coop/en/virtual-library/scientific-articles/cooperative-response-unemployment-ruraland-urban-turkey [accessed: 30.06.2017].
Putterman L. (2006). Labour-managed firms. Working Paper, Brown University, Department of Economics, 2006–18, 1.
Roelants B., Hyungsik E., Terrasi E. (2014). Cooperatives and Employment: a Global Report. CICOPA & Desjardins Group, 9, 15.
Sertel M.R. (1982). Workers and Incentives. Amsterdam: North Holland.
Sexton R.J., Iskow J. (1988). Factors Critical to the Success or Failure of Emerging Agricultural Cooperatives. Davis: University of California.
Smith, S.M. (2011). Cooperatives 101 – An Introduction To Agricultural Cooperatives And The Federal Regulations And Legal Concerns That Impact Them. Washington: US Department of Agriculture, 4. [Online] at: http://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/publishing/rpte_ereport/2010/5/te_smith.authcheckdam.pdf [accessed: 04.05.2016].
Steinherr A., Thisse J. (1979). Are labour managers really perverse? Economic Letters, 2, 137–142.
Ton Z. (2009). The Effect of Labour on Profitability: The Role of Quality. Harvard Business School. Working Papers, 09–040, 1.
USDA (1991). Advising People About Cooperatives. Cooperative Information Report, 29, 3–11.
Ward B. (1958). The firm in Illyria: Market syndicalism. American Economic Review, 48 (4), 566–589.
Whittam G., Talbot S. (2014). A review of Social and Employee-Owned Cooperative Business Models and their Potential to Reduce Poverty. Report No. 2. UWS-Oxfam Partnership.
Zeuli K.A., Cropp R. (2004). Cooperatives: Principles and practices in the 21st century. Madison: University of Wisconsin Cooperative Extension Publishing.
